[freedomtowernight_edited.jpg] 26th Parallel: Arza - Worth the Blogging?

Thursday, October 26, 2006

Arza - Worth the Blogging?

Rick is puzzled and disappointed at the relative lack of coverage in Cuban-American blogs concerning Ralph Arza and his derogatory remark towards school superintendent Rudy Crew, who is black. The comments from several others to the above-linked post are also critical of lack of C-A bloggage.

For the record, I did make a brief post about Arza here.

Also for the record, in case anyone is wondering, this Cuban-American blogger thinks Arza is a useless jerk. He doesn't represent Cuban-Americans. He doesn't even represents the Hialeah street he played ball in. He just represents Ralph Arza.

That above paragraph should be obvious to all reasonably intelligent people. No explanation is required.

Apparently, state representative Dorothy Bendross-Mindingall isn't one of those people. No explanation is required here, either.

Why hasn't this story been covered more by C-A bloggers? I can't and won't speak for my fellow bloggers whom I respect greatly. I won't even venture a guess. Honestly, I wasn't exactly chomping at the bit to blog about a stupid local politician who happens to be Cuban-American refer to a high-profile black man as a n----r. Maybe there's such a deep and deserved disillusionment of all politicians these days, that comments such as the one Arza made illicit a mere shrug from most people. I don't know, that's just a hunch.

I will say (and ask) this: Why should any C-A, blogger, politician or otherwise, be expected to make a comment on Arza as some sort of an "official" Cuban-American reaction? Do C-A's have something to prove vis-a-vis race relations that I'm not aware of?

With all due respect, I think Rick and others are focusing too much on the lack of C-A Arza blogging. Comparing this to the Tom Fiedler "chihuahua" comment is flawed on several levels.

First of all, the dynamics and facts involved in each case are totally different. In reality, they are two totally different stories about two totally different things.

Secondly, if one is going to erroneously use the Fiedler case as a comparison, it would help if they were similarly indignant of Fiedler's comment. Instead, some Cuban-American bloggers were criticized for taking the chihuahua reference personally. I wasn't offended by Fiedler's remark, but I understood why some C-As felt offended. Similarly, I understand why blacks would be offended by Arza's comments.

Honestly, and this is just my personal opinion, I would have liked to have seen Rick deliver as strong a criticism of Bendross-Mindingall's irresponsible statement as he did towards the lack of C-A reaction to Arza.

Finally, and at the risk of falling into the flawed comparison trap myself, no one in the Cuban community demanded a wholesale "anglo" apology after the Fiedler incident. Therefore, why isn't Bendross-Mindingall being grilled for demanding one from the C-A community? To not give equal time and criticism to the representative implies a double standard, whether intentional or not.

19 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Nigger" versus "chihuahua." Think about those words for a minute. Think about the ugliness, the history and the pain the first one brings to mind. In fact, it's so ugly, you won't even spell it out in your post. The second one brings up vision of a dog or maybe if you're a fast food freak, Taco Bell.

1st Point: There is no comparison in the words.

babalu tried to make hay of Fiedler's "racial slur" but no one, besides a handful of C-A extremists, bought it. Even you said here that it didn't offend you. It was more of Fiedler's "flippant" attitude regarding the ruckus that the extremist C-A community was making that caused you concern.

2nd Point: Fiedler's remark was a non-event and SotP (Alex) clearly identified it as such.

No one is comparing Fiedler's remark to Arza's racial slur. What we are comparing are some C-A's response to racism when it is coming from a C-A. What most people are saying and wondering is why some in the C-A community hyperventilate, write blog posts and demand for people to resign when C-A's are the supposed object of racism but virtually ignore real racism against other minorities in their community when the racist is a C-A. It's blatantly hypocritical and most people have no problem identifying it as such.

3rd Point: We didn't compare the statements, we compared the responses.

Here is Bendross-Mindingall's quote:

"If we let this go, are we saying this is what Cuban Americans think about us? This is what we think about ourselves: that we are niggers? That's his definition of me, that I'm a nigger. If you say that about one black person, you say that about us all. How dare he.''

If you're going to read the first sentence, which I should note is in the form of a question, not a statement, you need to consider the last sentence, too. "..are we saying this is what Cuban Americans think about us?", she asks. She seems to group C-A's together but then ends with, "How dare he." Certainly meaning Arza. By himself.

4th Point: I don't believe Bendross-Mindingall definitively threw all C-A's into one pot. An argument can be made both ways as to what she was saying.

Finally, I want to make a point that I think Tere has made. If Rudy Crew would have called Cuban-Americans "beaners" or "spics" or whatever other derogatory name you can think of, not once, but twice, I can bet you that the writers at babalu and most every other C-A in Miami-Dade would have gone through the roof and demanded that Crew be frog-marched out of his office and through the streets of Little Havana. And rightly so.

But when a C-A state politician who represents thousands of C-A's in South Florida uses the most ugliest, filthiest and derogatory names for an African-American, they are mute. It's wrong. It's hypocritical. And it's the most sinister type of racism.

.

11:24 PM, October 26, 2006  
Blogger Henry Louis Gomez said...

First off I don't usually cover local stories on my Cuba blog. The chihuahua comment is part of a continuing trend of conflict between the Herald and the Cuban American community. I blogged about the Chihuaha comment on Herald Watch because the story involved the Herald.

Besides Rudy Crew is hardly a sympathetic character. It's widely known that the number of Hispanics working at the school district offices has been greatly reduced during his tenure. He has no love for Latinos. In short Rudy Crew is an overpaid tool.

Rick from SotP is not my editor and therefore I don't give shit what he says about what I may write or not write. I post what I want when I want just like he does. If he want to make hay about Arza that's his prerogative but it doesn't make him holier than thou.

12:39 AM, October 27, 2006  
Blogger Robert said...

Rick,

The Fiedler case involved a dynamic that is totally different than Arza's. Remember, Fiedler's comments stemmed from the big mess involving the Marti Moonlighters, which is tied direcly to Cuba-related issues. This is why you saw a lot of coverage from C-A blogs on that particular issue, and also explains the strong reactions to Fiedler's comments afterwards.

As Henry and Jonathan noted, there's no reason why C-As should be expected to go out of their way to condemn a fellow C-A for making a racially insensitive remark to/about another individual. It's a personal issue and should be therefore be treated that way, not as an example of general C-A attitude or indifference. Again, the 2 cases are totally different and even if you didn't think the chihuahua statement was offensive (I don't), the reaction was understandable considering the overall situation.

I'm not convinced that Bendross-Mindingall was merely being pensive when making the comment/question about whether that is how Cuban-Americans think about blacks. There's a not-too hidden resentment behind those words, IMO.

One last thing, do you know how the Arza/Crew mess is being handled in the black community? I haven't seen much at all in the media.

8:25 AM, October 27, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I don't care what people choose to write in their blog. Don't want to cover this cause you don't care fine. But by using the justification that you you have ancedotal evidence that Crew has reduced the role of latinos and bringing up the fact that black people protested along side other racists is a very weak argument. It exemplifies why this community is fractured and dysfunctional. Everyone is racist and its tearing this place apart. I would think that its your duty as an american to decry racism, and injustice no matter which group it affects and which you belong to.

8:44 AM, October 27, 2006  
Blogger La Ventanita said...

No longer living in Miami, I consider myself an independent observer - specially since while in Miami I never listened to Radio Mambi instead I listened to Radio Paz.

Arza is an idiot, should be regarded as such and action taken as such. When did the actions of one person became the actions of an entire community? Just b/c people voted him in? Newsflash, politicians misrepresent themselves all the time to get votes; so unless Arza had in his previous campaign stated that he thought all blacks are N..r then the blame remains only on him.

Personally I believe some people do not deserve the media attention they get, b/c frankly that is what they want. I think Chavez and Fidel should be turned out of the airwaves, as should any Osama or other terrorist video.

10:11 AM, October 27, 2006  
Blogger Val Prieto said...

Hopefully, one of these days, Rick will finally be able to get that Babalu bug out of his ass once and for all.

What a tool.

11:27 AM, October 27, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yes, Val, it's all about you. It must be so exhausting for you to be the center of everyone's universe.

.

12:37 PM, October 27, 2006  
Blogger La Ventanita said...

Wasn't Mandela arrested b/c he was caught with amunition and explosives?

Alex, I'm sorry, but someone who hails Fidel as a great defender of Human Rights has neither character nor integrity in my eyes.

Now Eusebio Penalver, who spent more time in jail than Mandela, he had character and integrity.

4:01 PM, October 27, 2006  
Blogger Robert said...

Alex,

Sure there are Cubans that don't like blacks. Just like there are Irish-Americans, Italian-Americans, Polish-Americans, fill in the blank-Americans that don't like blacks. It's sad, but it's a reality for a small part of each community. So then why do Cuban-Americans bloggers in this particular case HAVE to make some sort of denouncement in order to clear all decent Cuban-Americans? That's really the bottom line here, and the fact that it was insinuated by a black politician is a sad statement and reflection on her, not Cuban-Americans. Sorry, my gut instinct tells me I shouldn't give her the benefit of the doubt.

As far as Mandela is concerned, he may have fought long and hard for racial equality, but when he willingly and enthusiastically aligns himself with someone like fidel, his character and integrity leave a lot to be desired.

4:02 PM, October 27, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I hope that everyone has been able to listen to the tape of Arza's voicemail message.

While there's no doubt that Arza was unprofessional and certainly made a complete fool of himself, what he said is a far cry from what has been reported in The Herald since Monday.

If everyone who said "my n---r" were considered a bigot for speaking that way, Miami would have more bigots per capita than the entire South during the height of slavery. I'd venture to say that a majority of the people who are so indignant about Arza's comments today, have said the same thing at least once in their life, and I guarantee that it wasn't while they were under the influence of alcohol.

Arza deserves to be censured by his colleagues and it is right for him to be excluded from any leadership positions in the House of Representatives; his conduct shows that he needs to change his ways before he can be held out as a leader. However, there is nothing in those recordings that betrays a hint of racism.

Arza didn't say: "you're a n-!", or "you're just like those n-!" or "n-lover". He simply said "my n-", sprinkled with a liberal dose "bitch". If anyone should be offended it's the National Organization for Women.

This is nothing more than a b.s. shitstorm created by The Herald and others who make their money through controversy.

Tom Fiedler clearly referred to Cubans as a buch of dogs; first as chihuahuas and then, in his "apology" as terriers. That was a bigoted remark and no one made a big deal about it. Fiedler is still at the Herald, sitting in judgment over everyone else.

Now, Arza says "my n-" and he is being presured to resign.

That's b.s.!

P.S.: If blacks don't like the use of the "n word", they shouldn't be pushing it on society in every rap song that they put out.

4:20 PM, October 27, 2006  
Blogger Alex said...

Yes LV. Sabotage was the actual charge. So what? Armed struggle against oppression is something to be proud of. As for Castro: a) he was very vocal internationally about releasing Mandela, something the US was not doing (some even claim the CIA gave Mandela up). b) Mandela has distanced himself from Castro and Kadhafi and others after his divorce. But in any case, his political beliefs don't take away one hour of the 27 years he spent in jail for fighting for his people. Just like Pe˜ãlver. Or Menoyo.

4:24 PM, October 27, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Please provide proof showing that Ralph Arza called Rudy Crew a "n-".

Ralph Arza only said "my n-" when signining off on a tirade directed at a filthy rat. Furthermore, these were private conversations.

I love how blacks are so aligned with the ACLU and all those liberal interests but when freedom of speech offends them, then they get mad.

As far as who lives in what neighborhood, take that trash somewhere else, it has no place in this discussion.

If you want to have a serious discussion, bring it. If you're going to spend your keystrokes spouting biggoted trash, take it somewhere else.

6:20 PM, October 27, 2006  
Blogger NicFitKid said...

Well Gus Barreiro certainly believes Arza called Rudy Crew a n----r, that's why he filed the ethics complaint that touched off this whole mess.

Ah, but Sojourner thinks Rep. Barreiro is a "filthy rat," so I doubt that will modify his opinions. Sojourner, why not simply call up Barreiro and let him know how you feel by leaving a descriptive message on his voicemail? It's not like he hasn't heard worse...

I'm with Alex on this one, everyone's dancing around the obvious. Of course there's racism within the Cuban American community directed at African-Americans, and of course there's resentment of Cubans within the African-American community. As someone who was born and raised in Miami-Dade, I'd have to be an oblivious fool to pretend this situation didn't exist. As for Bendross-Mindingall, she's an African-American politician playing to her base in an African-American district in a town with balkanized race relations. What did you expect, hugs and kisses? It's not rocket science, folks.

Everyone can dodge, duck, and weave all they like, but Arza isn't just some random schmo with wacky ideas (I'm enjoying how everyone has forgotten just how powerful Arza was about to become with the ascension of Marco Rubio), and we don't live in some idealized, atomized social universe of extreme individualism. Ethnic communities do exist in Miami-Dade county, and they do collide in ugly ways at times. While it's tempting to circle the wagons and protect one's own, the way forward is to condemn all forms of racism and bigotry without falling into this ridiculous ping pong of:

Fool1:"I'm not racist, you're the racist!"
Fool2:"Oh no, you're way more racist than me!"

10:30 PM, October 27, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Assuming that Arza used the "n-" word, does one word define a person? What about the 20+ years that Arza spent at Miami High teaching and coaching blacks and Hispanics? Did he give preferential treatment to the Hispanic kids? Did he refer to the black kids using the "n-" word?

I challenge anyone here to say that, at one point in their life, they have not uttered the "n-" word.

Furthermore, this controversy is not over Arza calling someone a "n-", but rather that he signed off on a profanity filled message by saying "my n-". Again, if saying "my n-" classifies someone as a bigot, then we're all bigots.

11:02 AM, October 28, 2006  
Blogger Robert said...

Nick,

Sure there's racism, I think we all agree that there's that element in every ethnic group. Why should Cubans be different, or even singled out in a general sense here? That's what I don't understand.

You're right, Arza isn't some random schmoe. He could very well speak for the minority of Cuban a-holes out there who love to throw around the n-word simply because they don't like a black person. No one is dancing around that. What I'm questioning - and you haven't addressed - is why should the Cuban community at large step up and prove that they are not a racist community? We don't demand that of any other group, so why are Cubans treated specially here?

As I said in the post, Arza is jerk. He speaks for himself, and no one who doesn't personally know the guy should have to explain that to anyone.

Also, you're being way too kind to Bendross-Mindingall. You seem to be giving her a sort of free pass by excusing her comment as just "an African-American politician playing to her base in an African-African district in a town with balkanized race relations". Reality, yes. But how about demanding she elevate herself above the mess like a true leader - HELL, a decent person - should. Instead, she's doing exactly what you say we shouldn't be doing as a community. Better yet, why don't we demand that the black community explain why they're not racist? Of course, you know the answer to that (no).

Up to now only a few people have criticized her divisive comments.

That's disappointing.

1:16 PM, October 28, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

LOL,


I think this is why Miami Cubans get a hard way to go when they step foot outside of Miami.

Yes, there is a lot bigotry in any nation. But if an educated, hard-working African-American is considered only a n-word. Then the C-A's can keep that stuff here in Dade.

Most of my friends in Broward know how to distinguish between the street thug, and the hard working type.

Someone ask why do Cubans move into black neighborhoods if they are so racist. The question i have is why does the (younger) generation walk, talk, and mimic the hip-hop culture. The rapper Pit-Bull seems to be the most recognized Cuban in the nation.

Finally, Johnathon and Robert, regardless of whether you wanted to blog about this issue or not. Good for you. It can only increase your profile and credibility. It was a good back and forth between the two camps.


Sincerey,

6:48 PM, October 28, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Pitbull is the most recognized Cuban? You wanna say hello to my little friend?

1:01 PM, October 29, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

THe comments are more interesting than the blog commentary. BTW, the "Fuck the fuck off" comment is perhaps the most inspiring thing I've read in years. Cheers to whoever posted that gem.

5:58 PM, October 29, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Cubes are way to self centered. Nobody outside of Miami cares one bit about their rants. They want the US to fight their battle. Assimilate, speak English and learn some manners. Then, let's talk.

11:59 PM, November 04, 2006  

Post a Comment

<< Home